BatchLoader

This gem provides a generic lazy batching mechanism to avoid N+1 DB queries, HTTP queries, etc.

Developers from these companies use BatchLoader:

Contents

• Highlights
• Usage
  • Why?
  • Basic example
  • How it works
  • RESTful API example
  • GraphQL example
  • Loading multiple items
  • Batch key
  • Caching
  • Replacing methods
• Installation
• API
• Related tools
• Implementation details
• Development
• Contributing
• Alternatives
• License
• Code of Conduct

Highlights

• Generic utility to avoid N+1 DB queries, HTTP requests, etc.
• Adapted Ruby implementation of battle-tested tools like Haskell Haxl, JS DataLoader, etc.
• Batching is isolated and lazy, load data in batch where and when it's needed.
• Automatically caches previous queries (identity map).
• Thread-safe (loader).
• No need to share batching through variables or custom defined classes.
• No dependencies, no monkey-patches, no extra primitives such as Promises.

Usage

Why?

Let's have a look at the code with N+1 queries:

def load_posts(ids)
  Post.where(id: ids)
end

posts = load_posts([1, 2, 3])  #      Posts      SELECT * FROM posts WHERE id IN (1, 2, 3)
                               #      _ ↓ _
                               #    ↙   ↓   ↘
users = posts.map do |post|    #   U    ↓    ↓   SELECT * FROM users WHERE id = 1
  post.user                    #   ↓    U    ↓   SELECT * FROM users WHERE id = 2
end                            #   ↓    ↓    U   SELECT * FROM users WHERE id = 3
                               #    ↘   ↓   ↙
                               #      ¯ ↓ ¯
puts users                     #      Users

The naive approach would be to preload dependent objects on the top level:

# With ORM in basic cases
def load_posts(ids)
  Post.where(id: ids).includes(:user)
end

# But without ORM or in more complicated cases you will have to do something like:
def load_posts(ids)
  # load posts
  posts = Post.where(id: ids)
  user_ids = posts.map(&:user_id)

  # load users
  users = User.where(id: user_ids)
  user_by_id = users.each_with_object({}) { |user, memo| memo[user.id] = user }

  # map user to post
  posts.each { |post| post.user = user_by_id[post.user_id] }
end

posts = load_posts([1, 2, 3])  #      Posts      SELECT * FROM posts WHERE id IN (1, 2, 3)
                               #      _ ↓ _      SELECT * FROM users WHERE id IN (1, 2, 3)
                               #    ↙   ↓   ↘
users = posts.map do |post|    #   U    ↓    ↓
  post.user                    #   ↓    U    ↓
end                            #   ↓    ↓    U
                               #    ↘   ↓   ↙
                               #      ¯ ↓ ¯
puts users                     #      Users

But the problem here is that load_posts now depends on the child association and knows that it has to preload data for future use. And it'll do it every time, even if it's not necessary. Can we do better? Sure!

Basic example

With BatchLoader we can rewrite the code above:

def load_posts(ids)
  Post.where(id: ids)
end

def load_user(post)
  BatchLoader.for(post.user_id).batch do |user_ids, loader|
    User.where(id: user_ids).each { |user| loader.call(user.id, user) }
  end
end

posts = load_posts([1, 2, 3])  #      Posts      SELECT * FROM posts WHERE id IN (1, 2, 3)
                               #      _ ↓ _
                               #    ↙   ↓   ↘
users = posts.map do |post|    #   BL   ↓    ↓
  load_user(post)              #   ↓    BL   ↓
end                            #   ↓    ↓    BL
                               #    ↘   ↓   ↙
                               #      ¯ ↓ ¯
puts users                     #      Users      SELECT * FROM users WHERE id IN (1, 2, 3)

As we can see, batching is isolated and described right in a place where it's needed.

How it works

In general, BatchLoader returns a lazy object. Each lazy object knows which data it needs to load and how to batch the query. As soon as you need to use the lazy objects, they will be automatically loaded once without N+1 queries.

So, when we call BatchLoader.for we pass an item (user_id) which should be collected and used for batching later. For the batch method, we pass a block which will use all the collected items (user_ids):

BatchLoader.for(post.user_id).batch do |user_ids, loader|
  ...
end

Inside the block we execute a batch query for our items (User.where). After that, all we have to do is to call loader by passing an item which was used in BatchLoader.for method (user_id) and the loaded object itself (user):

BatchLoader.for(post.user_id).batch do |user_ids, loader|
  User.where(id: user_ids).each { |user| loader.call(user.id, user) }
end

When we call any method on the lazy object, it'll be automatically loaded through batching for all instantiated BatchLoaders:

puts users # => SELECT * FROM users WHERE id IN (1, 2, 3)

For more information, see the Implementation details section.

RESTful API example

Now imagine we have a regular Rails app with N+1 HTTP requests:

# app/models/post.rb
class Post < ApplicationRecord
  def rating
    HttpClient.request(:get, "https://example.com/ratings/#{id}")
  end
end

# app/controllers/posts_controller.rb
class PostsController < ApplicationController
  def index
    posts = Post.limit(10)
    serialized_posts = posts.map { |post| {id: post.id, rating: post.rating} } # N+1 HTTP requests for each post.rating

    render json: serialized_posts
  end
end

As we can see, the code above will make N+1 HTTP requests, one for each post. Let's batch the requests with a gem called parallel:

class Post < ApplicationRecord
  def rating_lazy
    BatchLoader.for(post).batch do |posts, loader|
      Parallel.each(posts, in_threads: 10) { |post| loader.call(post, post.rating) }
    end
  end

  # ...
end

loader is thread-safe. So, if HttpClient is also thread-safe, then with parallel gem we can execute all HTTP requests concurrently in threads (there are some benchmarks for concurrent HTTP requests in Ruby). Thanks to Matz, MRI releases GIL when thread hits blocking I/O – HTTP request in our case.

In the controller, all we have to do is to replace post.rating with the lazy post.rating_lazy:

class PostsController < ApplicationController
  def index
    posts = Post.limit(10)
    serialized_posts = posts.map { |post| {id: post.id, rating: post.rating_lazy} }

    render json: serialized_posts
  end
end

BatchLoader caches the loaded values. To ensure that the cache is purged between requests in the app add the following middleware to your config/application.rb:

config.middleware.use BatchLoader::Middleware

See the Caching section for more information.

GraphQL example

Batching is particularly useful with GraphQL. Using such techniques as preloading data in advance to avoid N+1 queries can be very complicated, since a user can ask for any available fields in a query.

Let's take a look at the simple graphql-ruby schema example:

class MyProjectSchema < GraphQL::Schema
  query Types::QueryType
end

module Types
  class QueryType < Types::BaseObject
    field :posts, [PostType], null: false

    def posts
      Post.all
    end
  end
end

module Types
  class PostType < Types::BaseObject
    name "Post"

    field :user, UserType, null: false

    def user
      object.user # N+1 queries
    end
  end
end

module Types
  class UserType < Types::BaseObject
    name "User"

    field :name, String, null: false
  end
end

If we want to execute a simple query like the following, we will get N+1 queries for each post.user:

query = "
{
  posts {
    user {
      name
    }
  }
}
"
MyProjectSchema.execute(query)

To avoid this problem, all we have to do is to change the resolver to return BatchLoader::GraphQL (#32 explains why not just BatchLoader):

module Types
  class PostType < Types::BaseObject
    name "Post"

    field :user, UserType, null: false

    def user
      BatchLoader::GraphQL.for(object.user_id).batch do |user_ids, loader|
        User.where(id: user_ids).each { |user| loader.call(user.id, user) }
      end
    end
  end
end

And setup GraphQL to use the built-in lazy_resolve method:

class MyProjectSchema < GraphQL::Schema
  query Types::QueryType
  use BatchLoader::GraphQL
end

That's it.

Loading multiple items

For batches where there is no item in response to a call, we normally return nil. However, you can use :default_value to return something else instead:

BatchLoader.for(post.user_id).batch(default_value: NullUser.new) do |user_ids, loader|
  User.where(id: user_ids).each { |user| loader.call(user.id, user) }
end

For batches where the value is some kind of collection, such as an Array or Hash, loader also supports being called with a block, which yields the current value, and returns the next value. This is extremely useful for 1:Many (has_many) relationships:

BatchLoader.for(user.id).batch(default_value: []) do |user_ids, loader|
  Comment.where(user_id: user_ids).each do |comment|
    loader.call(comment.user_id) { |memo| memo << comment }
  end
end

Batch key

It's possible to reuse the same BatchLoader#batch block for loading different types of data by specifying a unique key.For example, with polymorphic associations:

def lazy_association(post)
  id = post.association_id
  key = post.association_type

  BatchLoader.for(id).batch(key: key) do |ids, loader, args|
    model = Object.const_get(args[:key])
    model.where(id: ids).each { |record| loader.call(record.id, record) }
  end
end
post1 = Post.save(association_id: 1, association_type: 'Tag')
post2 = Post.save(association_id: 1, association_type: 'Category')

lazy_association(post1) # SELECT * FROM tags WHERE id IN (1)
lazy_association(post2) # SELECT * FROM categories WHERE id IN (1)

It's also required to pass custom key when using BatchLoader with metaprogramming (e.g. eval).

Caching

By default BatchLoader caches the loaded values. You can test it by running something like:

def user_lazy(id)
  BatchLoader.for(id).batch do |ids, loader|
    User.where(id: ids).each { |user| loader.call(user.id, user) }
  end
end

puts user_lazy(1) # SELECT * FROM users WHERE id IN (1)
# => <#User:...>

puts user_lazy(1) # no request
# => <#User:...>

Usually, it's just enough to clear the cache between HTTP requests in the app. To do so, simply add the middleware:

use BatchLoader::Middleware

To drop the cache manually you can run:

puts user_lazy(1) # SELECT * FROM users WHERE id IN (1)
puts user_lazy(1) # no request

BatchLoader::Executor.clear_current

puts user_lazy(1) # SELECT * FROM users WHERE id IN (1)

In some rare cases it's useful to disable caching for BatchLoader. For example, in tests or after data mutations:

def user_lazy(id)
  BatchLoader.for(id).batch(cache: false) do |ids, loader|
    # ...
  end
end

puts user_lazy(1) # SELECT * FROM users WHERE id IN (1)
puts user_lazy(1) # SELECT * FROM users WHERE id IN (1)

If you set cache: false, it's likely you also want replace_methods: false (see below section).

Replacing methods

By default, BatchLoader replaces methods on its instance by calling #define_method after batching to copy methods from the loaded value.This consumes some time but allows to speed up any future method calls on the instance.In some cases, when there are a lot of instances with a huge number of defined methods, this initial process of replacing the methods can be slow.You may consider avoiding the "up front payment" and "pay as you go" with #method_missing by disabling the method replacement:

BatchLoader.for(id).batch(replace_methods: false) do |ids, loader|
  # ...
end

Installation

Add this line to your application's Gemfile:

gem 'batch-loader'

And then execute:

$ bundle

Or install it yourself as:

$ gem install batch-loader

API

BatchLoader.for(item).batch(
  default_value: default_value,
  cache: cache,
  replace_methods: replace_methods,
  key: key
) do |items, loader, args|
  # ...
end

Related tools

These gems are built by using BatchLoader:

• decidim-core – participatory democracy framework made with Ruby on Rails.
• ams_lazy_relationships – ActiveModel Serializers add-on for eliminating N+1 queries.
• batch-loader-active-record – ActiveRecord lazy association generator to avoid N+1 DB queries.

BatchLoader in other programming languages:

• batch_loader - Elixir implementation.

Implementation details

See the slides [37-42].

Development

After checking out the repo, run bin/setup to install dependencies. Then, run rake spec to run the tests. You can also run bin/console for an interactive prompt that will allow you to experiment.

To install this gem onto your local machine, run bundle exec rake install. To release a new version, update the version number in version.rb, and then run bundle exec rake release, which will create a git tag for the version, push git commits and tags, and push the .gem file to rubygems.org.

Contributing

Bug reports and pull requests are welcome on GitHub at https://github.com/exAspArk/batch-loader. This project is intended to be a safe, welcoming space for collaboration, and contributors are expected to adhere to the Contributor Covenant code of conduct.

Alternatives

There are some other Ruby implementations for batching such as:

• shopify/graphql-batch
• sheerun/dataloader

However, batch-loader has some differences:

• It is implemented for general usage and can be used not only with GraphQL. In fact, we use it for RESTful APIs and GraphQL on production at the same time.
• It doesn't try to mimic implementations in other programming languages which have an asynchronous nature. So, it doesn't load extra dependencies to bring such primitives as Promises, which are not very popular in Ruby community.Instead, it uses the idea of lazy objects, which are included in the Ruby standard library. These lazy objects allow one to return the necessary data at the end when it's necessary.
• It doesn't force you to share batching through variables or custom defined classes, just pass a block to the batch method.
• It doesn't require to return an array of the loaded objects in the same order as the passed items. I find it difficult to satisfy these constraints: to sort the loaded objects and add nil values for the missing ones. Instead, it provides the loader lambda which simply maps an item to the loaded object.
• It doesn't depend on any other external dependencies. For example, no need to load huge external libraries for thread-safety, the gem is thread-safe out of the box.

License

The gem is available as open source under the terms of the MIT License.

Code of Conduct

Everyone interacting in the Batch::Loader project’s codebases, issue trackers, chat rooms and mailing lists is expected to follow the code of conduct.