具有继承的Java Builder模式

Question

public class A extends SuperClass {
    private final String a1;
    ...

    private A(ABuilder builder) {
        super(builder);
        this.a1 = builder.a1;
        ...
    }

    public static class ABuilder extends SuperClassBuilder implements ABuilderInterface {
        private String a1;
        ...

        @Override
        public ABuilder withA1(String a1) {
            this.a1 = a1;
            return this;
        }
        ...

        @Override
        public SuperClass build() {
            return new A(this);
        }
    }
}

public interface ABuilderInterface extends SuperClassBuilderInterface {
    ABuilderInterface withA1(String a1);
    ...
}
...<interfaces for B and C>

public interface SuperClassBuilderInterface {
   SuperClassBuilderInterface withS1(String s1);
   ...
   SuperClass build();
}

// Usage of the builders:
public SuperClass foo() {
    return new A.ABuilder()
        .withA1(...) // returns ABuilderInterface
        ...
        .withS1(...) // returns SuperClassBuilderInterface
        ...
        .build();
}

public abstract class SuperClass {
private final String s1;
...

protected SuperClass(SuperClassBuilder builder) {
    this.s1 = builder.s1;
    ...
}

protected static abstract class SuperClassBuilder implements SuperClassBuilderInterface {
    private String s1;
    ...

    @Override
    public SuperClassBuilder withS1(String s1) {
        this.s1 = s1;
        return this;
    }
    ...

    @Override
    public abstract SuperClass build();
}
}

你更喜欢/建议哪一个？

Answer 1

修改超类的构建器以使用F绑定（也就是奇怪的重复模板模式）。

public interface SuperClassBuilderInterface<SELF extends SuperClassBuilderInterface<SELF>> {
    SELF withS1(String s1);
    // etc.
    Superclass build();
}

那么您就有：

class SuperClassBuilder<SELF extends SuperClassBuilder<SELF>> implements SuperClassBuilderInterface<SELF>

interface ABuilderInterface<SELF extends ABuilderInterface<SELF>> extends SuperClassBuilderInterface<SELF>

class ABuilder extends SuperClassBuilder<ABuilder> implements ABuilderInterface<ABuilder>

注意，superclassbuilder的实现必须包含窗体return(SELF)this；的未经检查的强制转换。类型系统理论上是足够强大的，不需要这样做，但是产生的编码可能会非常难看（请参阅此处），而且可能不值得这样做。